This is a Travesty
As soon as I heard this on the radio, it struck me as ridiculous. In the Indiana Voter ID case, John Paul Stevens wrote the opinion and drew upon the history of voter fraud that was so egregious and viscerally powerful, he included an excerpt in a footnote.
One infamous example is the New York City elections of 1868. William (Boss) Tweed set about solidifying and consolidating his control of the city. One local tough who worked for Boss Tweed, “Big Tim” Sullivan, insisted that his “repeaters” (individuals paid to vote multiple times) have whiskers:
“‘When you’ve voted ’em with their whiskers on, you take ’em to a barber and scrape off the chin fringe. Then you vote ’em again with the side lilacs and a mustache. Then to a barber again, off comes the sides and you vote ’em a third time with the mustache. If that ain’t enough and the box can stand a few more ballots, clean off the mustache and vote ’em plain face. That makes every one of ’em good for four votes.’ ” A. Callow, The Tweed Ring 210 (1966) (quoting M. Werner, Tammany Hall 439 (1928)).
This is a tremendous misuse of history. Stevens read a book on Tammany Hall forty years ago about elections abuses a hundred and forty years ago and has the gall to cite it in a landmark decision sure to disenfranchise thousands. Well played, old man; well played.
N.B. Anyone looking for a connection to my research won’t have to strain too hard. Stevens grew up in Hyde Park, went to UofC schools, and got his bachelor’s in English at Chicago. During the Ford administration, Edward Levi served as the Attorney General and was briefly considered for a seat on the U.S. Supreme Court; when opposition arose, Ford named Stevens.



